Job training sprawl costs US 18 billion dollars per year
Wednesday, February 09, 2011
By: Gregory Korte, USA TODAY
The federal government spends $18 billion a year on 47 separate
job training programs run by nine different agencies.
All but three programs overlap with others to provide the same
services to the same population, according to a government report
to be released today.
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that "little is
known about the effectiveness" of the programs because half haven't
had a performance review since 2004 and only five have ever had a
study to determine whether job seekers in the program do better
than those who don't participate.
"Here's just one example of how we're spending $18 billion, and
we don't have any idea of whether it's working or not," said Sen.
Tom Coburn, R-Okla., who requested the report with Sen. Mike
Enzi, R-Wyo. "This thing is so big and so out of control."
Managing that patchwork of federal programs is a network of 575
business-led local workforce boards running 1,300 one-stop job
centers.
Sherry Marshall, who runs one such agency in Cincinnati, answers
to a 45-member board.
More than 20 board seats are required by various local
governments, "and that's before I put a single business member on
the board," she said. Last year, at least a half-dozen federal
auditors from different agencies were at her office at one time to
look at the same records.
The result is a system that can be bewildering to job seekers
and the businesses that would hire them, she said.
"Some job seekers truthfully give up and go to work for
McDonald's," Marshall said. "Most employers find it incredibly
complicated. It's mind-boggling to me, and this has been my
profession for the last 12 years."
Streamlining overlapping programs is a priority of President
Obama, who promised in his State of the Union speech last month to
"merge, consolidate and reorganize the federal government" to make
it more efficient.
"There are 12 different agencies that deal with exports," Obama
said, and "at least five different agencies that deal with housing
policy."
An overhaul of job training isn't on the horizon, but Obama's
proposed budget last year would have cut five smaller programs,
said Moira Mack, a spokeswoman for the White House's Office of
Management and Budget. Congress never acted.
In a statement to USA TODAY, Assistant Secretary of Labor Jane
Oates defended the system, saying "diverse elements and multiple
suppliers" help local workforce boards tailor assistance to the
needs of job seekers and businesses.
Different programs allow the Labor Department to serve veterans,
dislocated workers, women, disabled workers, low-income youth,
Native Americans and migrants, she said. The report was "a timely
reminder that more work can be done" to reduce costs and improve
efficiency, she said.
Other agencies take issue with the report:
" 'Overlap' is not the same as 'duplication,' " Jim Esquea,
assistant secretary of Health and Human Services, told the GAO.