The Last Shuttle Launch: One giant leap backwards
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
The Last Shuttle Launch: One giant leap backwards
By: P.J. O'Rourke, The Weekly Standard
Merritt Island, Florida
My seven-year-old son, Cliff, watched the last space shuttle
launch from the NASA viewing stands at the Kennedy Space Center. He
had a spiritual experience of a kind that no amount of dragging him
to Mass or even Fenway Park has inspired. His little
face-seemingly made up entirely of open eyes-announced it:
"This is awe!" He didn't need to say anything and, having
forgotten to breathe, he probably couldn't. Indeed, for the first
waking moment in his 89 months on earth, he was silent.
The swooped delta of the Atlantis shuttle with its
orange gothic squid of a liquid fuel tank and its twin column,
party hat-topped solid-fuel boosters-the "full stack" as it's
called-is three-and-a-half miles away but looms nonetheless.
Perching on its launcher it is as tall as a 25-story building.
There's a flash below the engine nozzles. A fiery glory pours out
on every side. A few seconds later comes the joyful noise, a
trumpeting so powerful that the decibels will kill you if you're
closer than 800 feet.
My eyes were as wide as my son's, but, unlike him, I was
babbling as if I were a blind, deaf, and dumb man miraculously
cured: "This is light!" "This is sound!ˆ"
The full stack stands almost still, trembling with the strength
of 6,825,704 foot-pounds of thrust. Then it is risen-ascending on
a tower of smoke with the slow majesty befitting 2,030 tons of
wondrous engineering. The Atlantis, still joined to its
external tank and boosters, rolls gracefully onto its back,
embracing the heavens now instead of the Earth, and traces an arc
as grand as the curve of the space-time continuum. Then it
disappears into the layer of stratocumulus that had been
threatening for three days to scrub the launch.
Cliff made a small noise of protest. With a child's love of
things coming apart, he'd wanted to see the solid boosters detach
and fall into the ocean. But there was a better show. Rocket smoke
cast a scything shadow out to the horizon across the cloud tops
while at the launch site smoke still stood, vertical, immense, and
undissipating. "He took not away the pillar of cloud by day."
And He didn't. Congress and the White House did. Since the end
of the countdown about two minutes had passed, which seemed like an
era, and it was-the end of an era. That's that for the NASA
shuttle program and maybe for the whole idea of U.S. manned space
exploration.
We used to have presidents who liked to send Americans
places-Iraq, Afghanistan, the Moon, or Mars. But George W. Bush's
NASA Constellation program has been canceled. Its gigantic Ares V
rocket is off the drawing board. The Constellation's Orion
flight capsule has been renamed, in a telling translation into
GovSpeak, MPCV-"Multi-Purpose Crew Vehicle." What the multiple
purposes are supposed to be is anyone's guess. At the moment the
only way NASA can get a person into space is by paying Vladmir
Putin for a ride on the creaky old Soyuz. Looks like the
Russians won the space race after all. Meanwhile America's
government has not funded, or even proposed, anywhere new for
people to go beyond low Earth orbit. Never mind that the observable
universe is 92 billion light years across and would seem to offer
ample travel opportunities.
In a rare outburst of bureaucratic blunt truth, Michael
Leinbach, the Atlantis launch director, told colleagues at
the Kennedy Space Center, "We're all victims of poor policy out of
Washington. . . . I'm embarrassed that we don't have better
guidance."
On the trip to Florida I explained America's space exploration
to Cliff as well as I could. In a sense he understands better than
I do. To him space travel is not an extraordinary phenomenon but a
long-standing historical movement, an inevitability in the course
of human affairs. It's what the discovery and settlement of the
American West was to me when I was his age, before Manifest Destiny
was insulted in grade schools.
Cliff's reaction to the news that America will now lack a manned
spaceship was like hearing from Miss Sonnenberg, my second grade
teacher, that America had stopped with the Louisiana Purchase;
there was no war with Mexico, and the heck with Texas and
California.
Cliff and I went to the shuttle launch through the good offices
of our friend G. Ryan Faith, research analyst at the Space
Foundation, a nonprofit that brings together everyone involved in
space exploration-civilians, the military, commercial
entrepreneurs, and government space agencies from around the world.
I think aliens from Area 51 in Nevada would be welcome if they
existed. One purpose of the foundation is to build understanding,
support, and enthusiasm for what would be the coolest thing in the
world except all sorts of other worlds are involved so it's even
cooler than that.
Places for children in the NASA viewing stands are hard to come
by, reserved mostly for astronaut offspring. But I argued that if
you're going to promote the coolest thing in the world you need
testimony from someone who really uses those words in daily speech.
The Space Foundation put us in touch with the John H. Glenn
Research Center, which is, among other things, NASA's main
propulsion test facility, and let's hope they have something to
propel soon. James M. Free, the deputy director, extended
invitations, and Cliff became the National Aeronautics and Space
Administration's most vocal advocate-after his power of speech
returned.
Two nights before the launch the Glenn Center hosted a reception
in Cocoa Beach. Actual astronauts were in attendance, including
Rick Mastracchio, who has been on three shuttle missions and done
at least three space walks. He was wearing his blue NASA flight
suit. I introduced Cliff, and Cliff came right to the point about
the cancellation of the shuttle program. Well, not right to the
point. He had some questions of greater seven-year-old importance
to ask first. "When you were weightless, did you do a flip?"
"I sure did," Mastracchio said.
"Did you do a 'Misty'?" asked Cliff.
Mastracchio looked puzzled. "A snowboarding term," I explained.
"A back flip with a 540-degree spin."
"Good idea," said Mastracchio. "I'll try it next time."
But Cliff knew there won't be a lot of next times. Only four
Americans a year will fly on the Soyuz. A decade ago the
astronaut corps had about 150 men and women; now there are 61.
Cliff said, "Why are they putting the shuttle down?"
It was a nice choice of phrase. A country boy knows what happens
to old or unwanted animals, and he combined that with the term for
a schoolyard diss-the space geeks being razzed by the popular
kids from the Oval Office and the Hill.
Mastracchio answered diplomatically. NASA is working on a new
heavy-lift rocket. (Though it probably won't be ready until 2020,
leaving budget-cutters plenty of time to work.) Private commercial
manned flights are on the way. (But not before 2016, and only if
Congress is willing to pay for seats on board.) "By the time you're
ready to be an astronaut," Mastracchio said, "there will be plenty
of ways to go to space."
Cliff was not convinced. "Is the government," he asked, "just
being mean?"
A significant glance was exchanged between astronaut and parent
over Cliff's head.
So enough's enough, Christopher Columbus. Four voyages were
plenty. The natives are crabby. There's no gold out there. And Don
Quixote needs meds. Sancho Panza's pension plan has to be fully
funded. A wide variety of social and educational initiatives are
necessary for Dulcinea to achieve her full potential as a wench.
Anyway, if we need to go to the New World again, Sir Francis Drake
would consider having a Spaniard onboard to be a real
prize.
On July 20, 1969, at 10:56 p.m. I was in my off-campus apartment
staring at a black and white portable TV, a can of Budweiser in my
hand. "One small step . . . " I remember every detail. Where were
you and what were you doing when Lyndon Johnson signed Medicare
into law? Medicare cost $523 billion in 2010. NASA cost $18.7
billion, just 0.6 percent of federal spending. In fact, since
NASA's founding in 1958, its total spending has barely exceeded
what we pay for Medicare per annum. Would you rather reach into
infinity for 53 years or get old and sick for 12 months? In 2011
each American will give NASA about $60-the sun, the moon, and the
stars for less than the price of a month of basic cable.
Oh, maybe it's a waste of taxpayer money. But government wastes
taxpayer money. This is what government does. It can't be changed.
Our earliest evidence of government, in the ruins of Babylon and
Egypt, shows nothing but ziggurats and pyramids of wasted taxpayer
money, the TARP funds and shovel-ready stimulus programs of their
day. Let's waste taxpayer money putting that look back on Cliff's
face.