Congressional Budget OfficeSkip Navigation
Home Red Bullet Publications Red Bullet Cost Estimates Red Bullet About CBO Red Bullet Press Red Bullet Careers Red Bullet Contact Us Red Bullet Director's Blog Red Bullet   RSS
PDF
     
Growth in Medical Spending
by the Department of Defense
  September 2003  


Cover Graphic



Notes

Unless otherwise indicated, all years referred to in this study are fiscal years.

Numbers in the text and tables may not add up to totals because of rounding.

All dollar amounts are expressed in 2002 dollars (having been converted, when necessary, using the gross domestic product price deflator).

The photographs on the cover of this report appear courtesy of the Department of Defense. They were taken by Journalist 2nd Class Sybil McCarrol, U.S. Navy (top right); Tom Watanabe, for the U.S. Navy (bottom right); Senior Master Sgt. Dennis W. Goff, Air National Guard (bottom left); Photographer's Mate 2nd Class Steven Harbour, U.S. Navy (top left); and Cpl. Paula M. Fitzgerald, U.S. Marine Corps (center).





                
Preface

From fiscal year 1988 to 2003, the Department of Defense's (DoD's) spending on medical care almost doubled in real terms. That growth occurred despite large reductions in the size of the active-duty military force and a substantial reduction in the size of the military's own hospital system. This Congressional Budget Office (CBO) study--prepared at the request of the Chairman of the Senate Budget Committee--examines the reasons for those increases and considers directions for the future. Already, DoD's total spending on health care is more than half as large as its cash compensation. Looking forward, CBO's analysis examines how overall growth of health care costs in the economy could affect DoD's health care costs through 2020, as well how changes in benefits could do so. In keeping with CBO's mandate to provide objective, impartial analysis, this study makes no recommendations.

Allison Percy of CBO's National Security Division wrote the study under the general supervision of Deborah Clay-Mendez and J. Michael Gilmore. Sam Papenfuss of CBO's Budget Analysis Division prepared the cost estimates in Chapter 3 and wrote Appendix C under the general supervision of Jo Ann Vines and Peter H. Fontaine. Julie H. Topoleski of CBO's Health and Human Resources Division provided assistance with the projection methodology in Chapter 2. Carla Tighe Murray of the National Security Division helped review the manuscript for factual accuracy. Arlene Holen, Julie Lee, Robert P. Murphy, Carla Tighe Murray, Sam Papenfuss, Rachel Schmidt, Jo Ann Vines, and G. Thomas Woodward provided thoughtful comments on a draft of the study, as did external reviewer Paul F. Dickens.

John Skeen edited the study, and Christine Bogusz proofread it. Cindy Cleveland produced drafts of the manuscript, and Christian Spoor prepared the study for publication. Lenny Skutnik printed the initial copies, and Annette Kalicki prepared the electronic versions for CBO's Web site.

Douglas Holtz-Eakin
Director
September 2003





CONTENTS


  Summary
   
Historical Growth in the Department of Defense's Medical Spending
      Growth in per Capita Health Care Spending for the U.S. Population
      One-Time Occurrences Contributing to Growth in DoD's Medical Spending
      Other Factors Affecting the Pattern of Growth in DoD's Medical Spending
      Comparisons with Other Employers' Spending on Health Care
   
Projections of DoD's Future Medical Spending Under Current Policies
      Midrange Estimates
      Low Estimates
      High Estimates
   
The Effects of Legislative and Policy Changes on DoD's Projected Health Care Spending
      Future Health Care Spending Under Policies That Could Slow Growth
      Policies That Could Accelerate the Growth of Health Care Spending
   
  Appendix A
Background on the Department of Defense's Medical Coverage

Appendix B
Adjusting for the Changing Mix of the Department of Defense's Beneficiaries

Appendix C
Comparison of the Midrange Projections and CBO's Baseline for the Department of Defense's Medical Care



Tables
   
1.  Estimated Contributions to Growth in the Department of Defense's Medical Spending per Full-Time-Equivalent Beneficiary
2.  The Department of Defense's Future Medical Spending Under Three Scenarios
B-1.  Total Annual Medical Expenditures per Capita in a Civilian Population, by Age and Sex
C-1.  Comparison of This Study's Midrange Estimates and Those in CBO's Baseline
   
Figures
   
S-1.  Factors Contributing to the Growth in the Department of Defense's Medical Spending per Active-Duty Service Member, 1988 to 2003
S-2.  Medical Spending per Dollar of Cash Compensation for Service Members and for Federal and Private-Sector Employees, 1988 to 2020
1.  The Department of Defense's Historical Medical Spending and the Size of the Active-Duty Force
2.  The Department of Defense's Historical Medical Spending per Active-Duty Service Member and Relative to Cash Compensation, 1988 to 2003
3.  Factors Contributing to the Growth in the Department of Defense's Medical Spending per Active-Duty Service Member, 1988 to 2003
4.  Actual and Projected Growth in the Department of Defense's Medical Spending per Active-Duty Service Member, 1988 to 2003
5.  Medical Spending per Dollar of Cash Compensation for Service Members and for Federal and Private-Sector Employees, 1988 to 2020
6.  Timeline of Events for the Department of Defense's Medical Coverage
7.  The Department of Defense's Future Medical Spending per Active-Duty Service Member Under Three Scenarios, 2000 to 2020
A-1.  Out-of-Pocket Costs for Military Families Using the TRICARE Program and for Their Civilian Counterparts, 2002
B-1.  Relative Medical Costs for a Civilian Population, by Age and Sex
B-2.  Percentage of Care Provided by the TRICARE Program
B-3.  The Department of Defense's Health Care Beneficiaries and Full-Time-Equivalent Beneficiaries, 1988 to 2003
   
Boxes
   
1.  Accrual Budgeting for Retirees' Health Benefits
2.  Choosing a Range for Future Growth Projections
3.  Estimating the Savings from Introducing a Cafeteria Plan

Table of Contents Next Page