RELEASES
REPORT SHOWING THAT DRUG MANUFACTURER PRICES
ARE
MORE THAN DOUBLE FOR HUMANS THAN FOR ANIMALS
CHICAGO,
IL – U.S. Representative Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) today released a new report
that shows that drug manufacturers on average charge more than twice as
much when drugs are intended for human use than for animal use. As
a result of this action by the drug firms, Schakowsky said uninsured seniors
living in her district, which includes the Northern lake front and Northwest
side wards, Evanston, Niles, Skokie and Morton Grove, are forced to pay
"extortionist prices" for their medications.
"It
is shocking that drug manufacturers give a price break to Lassie and Benji
and then turn around and charge the elderly more than double for heart
and arthritis medication. This is a clear-cut case of price discrimination.
Maybe those seniors should just send their household pets to the vet to
get their owners' prescriptions filled," Schakowsky said.
Schakowsky
added, "Pets are our companions and we want to take care of them well.
Human beings also deserve the best care we can provide and should not be
charged more than double for the same drugs that our cats and dogs get."
The
report found that for the eight most popular drugs, manufacturers charge
an average of 151% more when the drug is intended for human use than when
it is intended for animal use. These eight brand name drugs are among
the top 200 drugs approved for use in the same form, but different dose,
for both humans and animals and are commonly obtained via outpatient prescription.
The heart medication Lanoxin, the 9th most popular drug sold in the United
States, has a price differential of 303%. This means manufacturers
charge four times more when Lanoxin is used by humans.
Drug Name |
Manufacturer of Human Version |
Human Use |
Manufacturer Price
(One Month Supply) |
Price Differential |
|
|
|
Animal Market |
Human Market |
|
Lanoxin |
Glaxo Wellcome |
Heart Failure |
$6.36 |
$25.65 |
303% |
Bactroban |
SmithKline Beecham |
Antibiotic |
$9.98 |
$31.56 |
216% |
Augmentin |
SmithKline Beecham |
Antibiotic |
$18.00 |
$56.40 |
213% |
Lodine |
American Home Products |
Arthritis |
$37.80 |
$108.90 |
188% |
Stadol |
Bristol Myers Squibb |
Pain Relief |
$25.48 |
$61.11 |
140% |
Lasix |
Hoechst Marion Roussel |
High Blood Pressure |
$4.80 |
$9.60 |
100% |
Vasotec |
Merck |
High Blood Pressure |
$51.30 |
$78.55 |
53% |
Amoxil |
SmithKline Beecham |
Antibiotic |
$16.20 |
$15.30 |
-6% |
Average for Eight Drugs |
|
|
151% |
In
addition, the report found that price gouging also exists for the eight
brand name drugs that are made for the human and animal markets in the
exact same form and dosage by the same or related companies. For
those drugs, the manufacturers charge on average 131% more when the drugs
are intended for human use instead of animal use. Medrol, when used to
treat arthritis, asthma, and allergies in humans, is 415% more expensive
than when it is used as an anti-inflammatory agent in dogs and cats.
Drug Name |
Manufacturer |
Human Use |
Manufacturer Price
(Monthly Supply) |
Price Differential |
|
|
|
Animal Market |
Human Market |
|
Medrol |
Pharmacia and Upjohn |
Arthritis; Allergies; Asthma |
$3.90 |
$20.10 |
415% |
Winstrol |
Sanofi |
Anemia; Renal Disease |
$5.40 |
$19.20 |
256% |
Lodine |
American Home Products |
Arthritis |
$37.80 |
$108.90 |
188% |
Robaxin |
A.H. Robins |
Pain Relief |
$15.00 |
$31.20 |
108% |
Vasotec |
Merck/Merial |
High Blood Pressure |
$51.30 |
$78.55 |
53% |
Cleocin |
Pharmacia and Upjohn |
Antibiotic |
$17.10 |
$22.20 |
30% |
Robinul |
A.H. Robins |
Ulcers |
$29.40 |
$29.98 |
2% |
Fulvicin U/F |
Schering |
Antifungal |
$38.40 |
$36.60 |
-5% |
Average for Eight Drugs |
|
|
131% |
"The
Drug manufacturers know that seniors make up 12% of the population, yet
use one-third of all prescriptions. So they take advantage of that
fact and charge seniors extortionist prices. As a result, we are seeing
the drug firms' profits soar and many seniors' quality of life decline,"
Schakowsky said
Schakowsky
said working to pass H.R. 664, the Prescription Drug Fairness for Seniors
Act, is one of her top priorities when she returns to Congress next year.
The bill, which is cosponsored by 137 House members, would allow pharmacies
to purchase drugs for Medicare beneficiaries at the same low prices available
to the federal government and other favored customers, including HMOs and
insurance companies. The legislation is estimated to reduce prices
by more than 40%.
The
report, released today by Schakowsky, was prepared by the Democratic staff
of the House Government Reform Committee and investigated drug prices at
the manufacturer level. The focus was the prices that drug manufacturers
charge wholesalers of human and animal drugs rather than the prices that
wholesalers charge pharmacists and veterinarians or the prices that pharmacists
and veterinarians charge individual consumers. Earlier this year, Schakowsky
had released two other reports that found that uninsured seniors living
in the 9th Congressional District are being gouged by the pharmaceutical
companies. The first report found uninsured seniors living in the
Chicago area pay 114% more for their medications as compared to HMOs and
insurance companies. The second report concluded that seniors living in
the Chicago area pay 80% more for the same drugs sold in Mexico and Canada.
"One
out of every eight seniors is forced to choose between buying food and
filling a prescription. That is shameful and inexcusable. No
one should have to make that painful and sometimes life threatening decision,"
Schakowsky said.
|