December 6th, 2002
By Wendy Solomon
The Morning Call
Naomi Godown went to see her allergist the other week, the place she
goes for treatment against the world's invisible enemies like pollen, dust
mites and mold. But Godown ended up running to the other end of Dr. Eric
Schenkel's waiting room in a panic to get away from another unseen, but
not unsmelled, foe. The culprit? Perfume.
One woman's Eternity can be another person's hell. Godown's temples
started to pound and her nose got stuffy when she caught a whiff of a woman's
fragrance. The new patient was not aware of the sign that says, ''Important.
For the comfort of our allergy and asthma patients, please do not wear
perfume or cologne when visiting our office.''
''I can't stand it,'' says Godown, 72, of Easton. ''It seems like she
just poured the perfume on.''
Like millions of people, Godown suffers from a sensitivity to fragrance,
a problem that can make life a challenge in public settings. They sneeze,
wheeze, tear, cough and choke around people who consider it a pleasant
and harmless scent.
Perfume may become the new tobacco. And, like the war on smoking, some
activists are waging a campaign for the right to have a scent-safe world
- in their workplaces, churches, restaurants and even mailboxes.
Irene Malbin, spokeswoman for the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association,
says workers' rights to a scent-free environment should not be legislated.
''I think it's basically a question of common sense and courtesy. People
should be able to work things out in terms of behavior that works for people
in the office.''
Besides, Malbin says, ''There's no medical or scientific evidence that
links fragrance to any serious health problems.''
Fragrance may be regarded as merely an unpleasant nuisance by some people,
such as disgust when a colleague goes a little heavy on the Old Spice or
suffering through second-hand perfume while wedged in between heavy users
at the symphony.
But for other people, scents can cause severe reactions.
Tearing, sneezing, wheezing, difficulty breathing, itchy eyes, runny
nose, dizziness, nausea and vomiting are just some of the symptoms people
suffer from airborne fragrance. The reactions are not considered an allergy,
but an irritation or sensitivity, says Dr. Schenkel, director of the Valley
Allergy and Asthma Treatment Center in Easton.
''It may sound like a subtle difference, but an allergy involves the
body's immune system. Allergies need the genetics to react and for the
body to release an allergy chemical like histamine,'' Schenkel says. Whereas
pollen, dust mites and dander are considered allergens, perfumes can be
irritants to the mucous membranes.
For most people, airborne substances such as perfume, gasoline or cigarette
smoke bypass irritation receptors in the nose, says Dr. Philip Gallagher,
a fellow of the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology and
former president of the Pennsylvania Allergy Society.
But for others, certain smells stimulate irritation receptors in the
nose, which are like nerve endings, and trigger a reflex through the involuntary
nervous system that can be similar to an allergy, he says.
People with allergies or asthma tend to be more sensitive to perfume
and other irritants, he says.
Perfume can trigger a bronchial spasm in some of the 17 million Americans
who suffer from asthma or cause a number of reactions, from headaches to
upper respiratory problems, in the 50 million allergy sufferers, according
to numerous groups from the American Lung Association to the Asthma and
Allergy Foundation of America.
''It doesn't cause their asthma - it triggers the symptoms of the asthma
for a patient who already has the problem,'' Gallagher notes.
John Williams, regional vice president for the American Lung Association
in Bethlehem, says his organization recommends that people with lung disease
and their family not wear strong perfume and to avoid it in the general
population.
''We recommend to any of our people with asthma to avoid their triggers.
It could be tobacco smoke or it could be perfume, but they should leave
that environment,'' Williams says.
Schenkel says perfume sensitivity is an increasingly common problem.
''I think more people are wearing perfume and colognes. We're spending
more time indoors and the ventilation might not be the greatest; everything
is hermetically sealed. I've been in elevators and sat behind someone in
a movie theater and gotten a severe headache.''
Godown, who suffers from numerous allergies and asthma, first noticed
her reaction to perfume when her husband gave her a bottle of Evening in
Paris when they were courting in 1946. She finally had to tell him she
couldn't wear it, but that didn't prevent her exposure to other's fragrances.
''I used to get headaches so bad I could cry,'' she says. ''I used to
work in the housewares section at Laneco and sometimes someone would spray
perfume that would drift over. I had to leave the area or put Vaseline
up my nose,'' she says. If Godown visits a department store, she must cover
her nose and mouth with a handkerchief if she ventures near the perfume
counters.
In October, a Salt Lake City nurse sued the hospital where she works,
claiming her employer violated her civil rights. The nurse said she was
made the office laughingstock after she complained that her co-workers'
perfumes and colognes made her sick. She says supervisors failed to adequately
accommodate her or enforce the hospital's policy prohibiting heavy perfumes.
''Scent is a real problem in the workplace today and we are becoming
more and more aware of it as an issue,'' says Peter Post, co-director of
The Emily Post Institute and author of ''The Etiquette Advantage in Business:
Personal Skills for Professional Success.''
''It needs to be taken seriously. The scent we would wear in social
life can have a real negative effect on people who have not chosen to be
with us or who have to be with us.''
Post suggests employees either tell the offending colleague in a respectful
manner or tell a supervisor about the problem. ''We're looking to deal
with it on a reasonable level. That's really what the goal is here. You
have a right to a workplace you are comfortable in and that's not physically
making you ill in some way.''
Some businesses instituted fragrance policies or have protocol they
follow if an employee complains about odors. Lehigh Valley Hospital mandates
employees wear some form of deodorant. Their dress code policy reads: ''Due
to close contact with others, deodorant or antiperspirant shall be worn.
A light cologne or perfume is acceptable.''
Because it is a health-care facility, LVH respects patients' complaints
regarding smells, even traditionally pleasant ones, says Brian Downs, a
spokesman. ''Maybe you enjoy the smell of coffee; however, if a person
comes into a physician's office who is not feeling well, even the smell
of coffee might make them sick.''
People who suffer from perfume sensitivity may face an uphill battle,
particularly in December, traditionally the best-selling month for fragrances.
The $6 billion U.S. fragrance market is the largest in the world, more
than triple the size of the next national market, France. And the $2.2
billion men's fragrance market in the United States is growing, too, according
to industry trade journals. The growing popularity of aromatherapy, fragranced
candles and bath and body products is continuing to scent the air.
Consumers may start to see more scented ads in magazines and direct
mail. The U.S. fragrance industry is trying to appeal not only to the eyes
in its advertisements, but to the nose through scented strips or scratch-and-sniff
patches. The ads may be effective, because 61 percent of all adults who
smelled a scent strip in a magazine in the past three months said they
find them somewhat or very helpful when choosing a fragrance, according
to a study commissioned by Vertis Direct Marketing Services.
Customers who consider perfumed ads, catalogs and bills an affront to
their senses can often request scent-free subscriptions or bills. About
15,000 of The Bon-Ton department store's 600,000 mailings a year to customers
are scent-free, says Mary Kerr, spokeswoman.
Some groups are pushing for better labeling of fragrances used in products
so that people with sensitivities will be able to identify and avoid their
triggers. Some fragrances can contain up to 250 ingredients, according
to the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America. Several years ago, the
Environmental Health Network, an advocacy group based in California, submitted
a petition to the Food and Drug Administration to have Eternity eau de
parfum by Calvin Klein declared misbranded because of concerns over its
ingredients.
The European Union may consider legislation requiring perfume manufacturers
to list ingredients on their products, but the industry is balking because
of fears that would give away trade secrets.
And U.S. Rep. Jan Schakowsky, D-Ill., plans to reintroduce next year
the Safe Notification and Information for Fragrances Act, or SNIFF, co-sponsored
by Rep. Chaka Fattah, D-Pa.
The bill would amend legislation to require fragrances containing known
toxic substances or allergens to be labeled accordingly. ''Congresswoman
Schakowsky believes consumers have a right to know what's in these perfumes.
Consumers have a rgiht to make informed decisicions,'' says her spokesman
Nadeam Elshami.
|