06/26/02
By Jill Zuckman
Chicago Tribune
When President Bush warned against turf battles engulfing his proposal
for a new Department of Homeland Security, he might well have been worrying
how fans of the venerable U.S. Coast Guard would react.
The answer: Not well. The fight over the Coast Guard, founded in 1790
to collect customs at sea, is perhaps the most dramatic example of the
battles under way as Bush tries to reorganize the federal bureaucracy to
better protect the nation from terrorism. Agencies that handle everything
from visas to animal inspections to scientific research are scheduled to
be absorbed into the new department, raising concerns across America that
their primary missions could be undercut.
On Capitol Hill, Democrats and Republicans from the House to the Senate
are in a frenzy over where in the federal bureaucracy the Coast Guard should
reside. They also are fretting about whether the guard would retain its
mandate to rescue fishermen, catch drug smugglers, clean up oil spills
and stop foreign fishing vessels from poaching in American waters while
at the same time preventing terrorists from invading the nation's ports.
Some lawmakers have gone so far as to suggest that the Coast Guard be
split in two, with a security branch in the new department and a safety
branch remaining in the Department of Transportation. Others have said
they could accept the move to the Department of Homeland Security if the
Department of Transportation could still oversee certain functions. Yet
others have said it does not matter where the Coast Guard falls within
the government, as long as it gets more money.
"Before we jump off the bridge, it's important we know how deep the
water is," said Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska), chairman of the Transportation
and Infrastructure Committee, which oversees the Coast Guard. "I'm not
going to be railroaded into supporting an unworkable bill."
Young already has begun lobbying his colleagues in the House to keep
the Coast Guard under the Department of Transportation. With an expensive
transportation bill coming up next year, lawmakers looking for highway
and bridge projects may not want to cross him.
Indeed, the Coast Guard has numerous and powerful allies on Capitol
Hill, particularly those from states bordering the oceans and Great Lakes.
"The mission of the Coast Guard literally involves a matter of life
and death for our fishermen," Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) said.
Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.) said she is worried that Coast Guard duties
not involving homeland security, such as rescuing sailors on Lake Michigan,
could get short shrift under the new mission.
"The Coast Guard has been enormously valuable to us," said Schakowsky.
"We want to make sure that the functions performed for the City of Chicago
don't get second-class status if and when it's rolled into a new department."
Tom Ridge, the director of the Office of Homeland Security, has heard
from Schakowsky, Collins, Young and others during his testimony before
Congress this week and last.
Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.), for example, plans to question Ridge
closely Wednesday at a Judiciary Committee hearing on what Kennedy considers
to be insufficient funding for the Coast Guard's enormous new responsibilities.
Moreover, Sen. Ted Stevens (R-Alaska), the ranking member on the powerful
Appropriations Committee, has lectured Ridge in public and in private.
"It took us 20 years to get the foreign nations out of our waters and
to restore the capability of protecting the reproductivity of the fisheries
off our shore," Stevens told Ridge.
"If the result of this legislation is to take the Coast Guard off of
that mission, to deny us the ability to maintain the boats that are necessary
to assure the fisheries patrol, we would lose the largest biomass of fish
that has the greatest productivity for the future of the world."
Though lawmakers are unified in their concern for the Coast Guard, there
is little consensus on where it belongs in the hierarchy.
Some members of Congress had in recent years proposed that the Coast
Guard be part of the Department of Defense. Before it was shifted in 1967
to the new Transportation Department, the Coast Guard was in the Treasury
Department.
James Lewis, director of the technology and public policy program at
the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said it took at least
10 years to reorganize the military and create a Department of Defense
after the idea was raised in 1943. A decade later, President Dwight Eisenhower
was still tinkering with the flow chart.
"The odds of us getting this totally right in the first place are zero,"
Lewis said. "None of this is going to be easy, and the Coast Guard part
is the hardest to bite off."
Adm. Thomas Collins, commandant of the Coast Guard, said his agency
wants to move under the jurisdiction of the new department, where it would
dwarf the Immigration and Naturalization Service, the Federal Emergency
Management Agency and the Customs Service, among others.
"The time is now for some organizational adjustment, and I support that,"
Collins said.
What he doesn't want is to divide the Coast Guard between Cabinet departments.
"I think that is the worst outcome that could possibly happen," Collins
said, explaining that Coast Guard cutters perform multiple tasks that cannot
be separated.
"It's bad stewardship and it's a very bad business case to pull us apart,"
he said, describing the idea as "a fall-on-your-sword issue." And he said
the Coast Guard's traditional missions will not fall by the wayside.
House Majority Leader Dick Armey (R-Texas) provided little assurance
to Young during a private meeting Monday that the Coast Guard would stay
in the Department of Transportation.
"I don't think there is any member of Congress who would want to see
the traditional mission of the Coast Guard diminished," Armey said. The
best he could offer Young, however, was to say that "no one means anyone
any harm in this process."
Young, meanwhile, is not backing down. He doesn't like the homeland
security bill, and he's annoyed that the president keeps minimizing his
concerns by talking about turf wars.
"When I was at the White House I told him not to do that," said Young,
whose home state of Alaska makes up half the nation's coast line. "That's
not his business."
|