06/20/02
By David Bacon
Inter Press Service
Bonita, the word for beautiful in Spanish, is the trademark found on
bananas at markets here and across the country. But Bonita is not the word
used by workers to describe their experience growing, harvesting, and packing
the nearly perfect fruit.
The Bonita label belongs to Alfredo Noboa, the largest banana exporter
in Ecuador. Noboa also is running for election to succeed Gustavo Noboa
(no direct relation) as president of Ecuador. His plantations are the site
of what workers and observers alike describe as gross and violent abuses
against human rights and national law. U.S. unions are protesting the treatment
of workers who went on strike to protest conditions at Noboa.
In April, some 1,400 Noboa company workers organized a union on seven
plantations in Hacienda Los Alamos. They asked for what was already, in
many cases, legally required from their employer.
Ecuadorian law says workers must be enrolled in the national health
care system, but on banana plantations, virtually no one is. They wanted
higher wages -- their average wage is less than the legal minimum. And
they wanted legal recognition for their union, a right guaranteed by Ecuadorian
law. Hardly any of the 150,000 banana workers in Ecuador, the largest banana
workforce in Latin America, have a union.
Company reaction was swift, according to workers and observers. Some
124 workers were fired almost immediately. Others on temporary contract
were told there was no more work. Efforts to negotiate with Bonita got
nowhere, and after three more union activists were fired, the workers walked
out on strike on May 6.
Nine days later, 400 hooded men armed with rifles arrived at one of
the plantations in a Noboa company truck. They invaded the strikers' homes
and took the possessions of many workers, said Jan Nimmo, a Scottish observer
for BananaLink, an international organization supporting banana workers.
"They banged on the doors with rifle butts and dragged workers from
their beds kicking them and hitting them," Nimmo said, relating what strikers
had told her. The workers were "told that they were being taken to be killed
and dumped in the river."
When strikers tried to resist, some were shot. The leg of 26-year-old
Mauro Romero was amputated as a result of his wounds. On the second evening,
the armed men shot into the crowd of strikers, wounding more. A large police
contingent arrived the following day, but strikers who were living in company
housing on the plantations were expelled and strikebreakers were brought
in to restart production.
Los Alamos Hacienda workers also said they have been told, on threat
of being fired, to join their employer's political party, the PRIAN.
Xavier Monge, a spokesperson for the Exportadora Bananera Noboa company,
told reporters the company has resumed harvesting bananas on the plantations,
and that the strike is over.
The Federacion Nacional de Campesinos Libres del Ecuador (FENACLE),
to which the strikers' union belongs, says the strike movement is spreading,
not ending.
In the United States, the Costco retail chain, having been persuaded
by the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, has sent a letter to Noboa
expressing concern.
After a representative of the American Center for International Labor
Solidarity, Liz O'Connor, relayed news from the strikers following a visit
to the plantations, AFL-CIO President John Sweeney and Jim Spinosa, head
of the International Longshore and Warehousee Union, also have written
to Noboa. Sweeney's is the premier U.S. labor federation.
Members of Congress Jan Schakowsky and George Miller have sent their
assistants to investigate the situation on the Hacienda Los Alamos plantations
and to meet Noboa officials.
Support also has come from the International Union of Foodworkers and
the International Transport Federation. The final word, labor activists
say, might come from U.S. consumers -- if they begin to treat Bonita with
the same disdain they reserved for table grapes two decades ago, for much
the same reason.
One out of every four bananas harvested in Ecuador is sold in a U.S.
supermarket or to a school or other institution, making the country by
far the largest source for U.S. consumers. Noboa is the biggest producer,
followed by a consortium called La Favorita, and then the U.S. companies
Chiquita (United Brands), Dole Farming Company, and Del Monte.
Together, these companies control the world market in bananas. In the
last decade, they have shifted much of their production to Ecuador, which
is now the world's largest exporter. The next four are Colombia, Panama,
Guatemala and Costa Rica.
Ecuador's non-union status is the big attraction. More than 90 percent
of the banana workers in Colombia and Panama belong to unions, and 40 percent
in Guatemala. Only Costa Rica's six percent approaches Ecuador's one percent
-- or 1,650 banana workers -- who are organized.
Success in the current strike would do more than double Ecuador's banana
union membership. It would also deprive its employers of the low-wage advantage
they currently enjoy. Unions would also threaten the advantages they derive
from their contracting system, which is not as prevalent in other countries.
According to a recent report on child labor on Ecuadorian banana plantations
by Human Rights Watch, the average daily wage of a banana worker is $ 5.44.
This is 41 cents below the legal minimum. The Ministry of Labor says it
takes $ 288 a month to support a family, or about $ 11.07 per day for a
six-day week. The combined income of two working adults barely covers basic
needs.
Although the law also forbids employing minors in dangerous jobs, work
on banana plantations exposes them to pesticides so hazardous that the
Environmental Protection Agency bans them in the United States.
|