Chicago Tribune
March 8, 2002 Wednesday
By Jill Zuckman, Washington Bureau
The House on Thursday overwhelmingly passed a package of unemployment
benefits and limited tax cuts designed to help people and businesses hurt
by the economic downturn after Sept. 11.
The Senate is expected to follow suit, perhaps as early as Friday. The
likely boost to the economy--at a cost of $94 billion over five years--comes
as Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan and other economists have begun
to signal that the recession is ending.
Nevertheless, lawmakers on both sides of the Capitol and on both sides
of the aisle said the legislation is essential to give jobless workers
and struggling businesses a bit more support.
"I would say that we are not completely out of this recession yet, and
we are going to see people continue to lose jobs," said House Speaker Dennis
Hastert (R-Ill.).
Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-S.D.) called the bill "overdue
and awfully late."
The House passed the legislation 417-3, with every member of the Illinois
delegation voting for it except Democratic Rep. Rod Blagojevich, who was
absent.
'Blue Dogs' reject measure
Voting against the measure were so-called Blue Dog Democrats, who advocate
a cautious fiscal approach: Reps. Alan Boyd of Florida, Gene Taylor of
Mississippi and Charles Stenholm of Texas.
At the White House, spokesman Ari Fleischer said President Bush would
sign the bill, even though it does not include everything he asked for.
"The president is concerned that we don't have a jobless recovery,"
Fleischer said. "It's a compromise. The president is saying today he will
support a compromise."
Boost in jobless aid
The measure would extend unemployment benefits by 13 weeks beyond the
standard 26 weeks of aid generally provided to jobless workers. About 80,000
people a week are exhausting their regular benefits, according to the Labor
Department, and about 1.6 million people have used up their benefits since
the Sept. 11 attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon dealt a
blow to the economy, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
In addition, the bill would provide businesses with a 30 percent tax
write-off for capital investment, create "liberty zones" to spur economic
development in lower Manhattan and renew several popular but expiring tax
provisions.
Thursday's action was the fourth time the House had taken up such a
measure, but this time Republican leaders slashed the price tag and removed
the most controversial tax provisions, such as expediting income tax rate
cuts, providing corporate tax relief and giving health-care tax credits
to the unemployed.
Previous versions of the bill failed in the Senate. Instead, senators
twice approved an extension of unemployment benefits by a unanimous vote
without tacking on the tax cuts sought by the House.
Finger-pointing abounds
Lawmakers spent the day Thursday arguing over who was to blame for the
delay and who had caved in to the other side.
Hastert denied that he had given in to the Senate by taking out all
of the controversial tax provisions.
"We did not back up. We did not wave the white flag or retreat," Hastert
said, vowing to put together a new tax bill in the near future.
Instead, he castigated the upper chamber:
"The Senate has been belligerent. The Senate has not moved on legislation,"
Hastert said.
Democratic Leader Richard Gephardt of Missouri said it was because of
House Republicans that unemployed workers had been in limbo for months.
"It was only the recalcitrance and the desire of the Republican leadership
in the House to put all of this ideological baggage on it that kept it
from passing four months ago," Gephardt said.
Democrats and Republicans are still at odds over how to help the unemployed
obtain health insurance.
For the most part, Republicans wanted to provide tax credits to reimburse
jobless workers for the money they spent buying health insurance. But Democrats,
saying most people without jobs could not afford the cost of health coverage
up front, urged that insurance be provided through the workers' former
employers.
After months of bickering, many rank-and-file House Republicans concerned
about this year's elections began pushing their leaders to move unemployment
benefits in a package that could become law.
"Our unemployment continues to go up, not down, with each round of Boeing
layoffs," said Rep. Jennifer Dunn (R-Wash.), speaking in support of the
legislation.
Rep. Phil English (R-Pa.) called the latest version of the measure "the
right mix to provide the economy with some relief at a time when it's still
dragging."
Airline aid disparaged
But Democrats continued to express frustration that the House quickly
bailed out the airlines and their executives with $15 billion in loans
and grants immediately after the Sept. 11 attacks, but took far longer
to help the workers who lost their jobs.
"They promised," said Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.). "People voted for
the bailout with the promise we'll deal with the workers who have lost
their jobs . . . Here we are four months later."
|