Sen. Dick Durbin will
introduce a package of legislative reforms Tuesday designed to bolster the
safety of school meals by requiring more stringent tests for disease-causing
organisms and by giving school authorities more information about the safety
records of food suppliers.
"We simply cannot afford to let another term pass by with failing grades for
the distribution of safe food," Durbin (D-Ill.) said.
Durbin's proposals were spurred by a Tribune series in December 2001 that
exposed pervasive breakdowns in the government system that regulates school
meals, his spokeswoman said.
The Safe School Food Act would fill the gaps in the inspection, testing,
procurement and preparation of food served to students, Durbin said, and it
would provide school officials with the tools and information to help them
prevent food-borne illness.
Current rules defended
Some members of the school food services industry questioned the need for new
regulations.
"We have a regulatory framework under which USDA and FDA recalls have worked,
and worked well," said Tim Willard, a spokesman for the National Food
Processors Association, referring to the Department of Agriculture and the Food
and Drug Administration.
During the last decade, school food illness outbreaks have become increasingly
frequent as suppliers use distributors and brokers to ship prepackaged and
frozen meals to schools across the country. Food produced in one factory may be
reworked in a second, then passed through a series of shipping companies. The
brokers who deliver meals to schools often do not tell authorities where they
got the food, and they rarely provide inspection reports on those plants.
Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.), who
plans to introduce companion legislation in the House, said the act will help
"put an end to large-scale outbreaks of food-borne illness."
Industry-backed confidentiality provisions do not allow state and local school
officials to have access to the distribution records of food companies, even
during a recall. Durbin's legislation would create methods for sharing
information on food suppliers with the appropriate state education personnel.
And the act would create an advisory committee made up of education and health
officials, consumer groups and industry representatives to recommend ways of
sharing additional information on school lunch suppliers.
About 17 percent of the food served in schools is donated by the federal
government and undergoes stringent Agriculture Department testing for dangerous
pathogens. But the remaining 83 percent of school food is purchased by states
and is not subject to the same standards. Durbin's act would give the
Agriculture Department the authority to require the same salmonella, E. coli
and listeria testing of commercially purchased school foods as that required of
USDA-donated commodities.
Marilyn Swanson, director of education and training at the University of
Mississippi's National Food Service Management Institute, applauded the
proposed expansion of the donated-commodities guidelines. But Swanson, who said
her organization helps schools deal with food recalls, called the current
voluntary inspection standards "not bad," adding that it is always in a food
company's interest to "make sure foods they are distributing are the safest
they can possibly be."
Ruth Jonen, food services director for Palatine Township High School District
211 in Chicago's northwest suburbs, defended the quality and safety of foods
served in schools, saying they "by and large use the same food distributors as
the restaurant down the road."
Julie Quick, an Agriculture Department spokeswoman, said department officials
have not yet seen Durbin's bill and could not comment on it.
Requirements proposed
Durbin's proposal would also:
- Increase the frequency of sampling for E. coli and salmonella in ground meats
donated by the USDA, from one sample per day to four, with a composite test
done at the end of the day to give a more accurate reading of meat processed
throughout the day. The proposed laws also would add a new requirement for
listeria testing in firms producing ready-to-eat meat and poultry products.
- Require quarterly inspections of donated commodities regulated by the FDA,
such as fruits and vegetables. Currently, these suppliers undergo an annual,
on-site audit.
- Allow for mandatory recalls of unsafe school food. Currently, food recalls
are voluntary. Under Durbin's legislation, the agriculture secretary could
require food companies to immediately stop distributing tainted food. States
would also have to provide public notice whenever school food was subject to a
recall because it contained the most dangerous pathogens, such as E. coli.
- Increase state and local annual cafeteria inspections to twice a year as
recommended by the FDA, and require the cafeteria inspection reports be posted
and made available to the public. The agriculture secretary would perform an
annual review of the state audits of these inspections. |