Printer
Friendly Version
Statement
by U.S. Senator Ron Wyden Calling for Congress to Vote on Iraq
April 7, 2006
Washington, DC – Unofficial
transcript of U.S. Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) statement follows:
MR. PRESIDENT,
I RISE THIS AFTERNOON TO OFFER A SIMPLE PROPOSITION. CONGRESS
SHOULD ACT LIKE A CO-EQUAL BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT AND VOTE ON WHETHER
OR NOT TO KEEP AMERICAN TROOPS IN IRAQ FOR AT LEAST THREE MORE
YEARS. LATE LAST MONTH THE PRESIDENT TOLD THE AMERICAN PEOPLE
THAT IT IS HIS INTENT TO KEEP AMERICAN SOLDIERS IN IRAQ THROUGH
THE END OF HIS TERM IN OFFICE. HE HAS NEVER BEFORE MADE SUCH A
SWEEPING COMMITMENT.
WHEN THE SENATE VOTED IN OCTOBER
OF 2002 TO SEND TROOPS TO IRAQ, FEW AMERICANS BELIEVED THEN THAT
THE U.S. MILITARY WOULD BE IN IRAQ IN 2006, LET ALONE 2009 OR
BEYOND. BASED ON WHAT THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION SAID THEN, AMERICANS
WOULD BE JUSTIFIED IN THINKING THAT BY NOW IRAQ WOULD BE FREE
AND DEMOCRATIC. BASED ON WHAT THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION SAID THEN,
AMERICANS WOULD BE JUSTIFIED IN THINKING THAT BY NOW IRAQ WOULD
BE STABLE AND SELF-SUPPORTING. BASED ON WHAT THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION
SAID THEN, AMERICANS WOULD BE JUSTIFIED IN THINKING OF NOW THE
VAST MAJORITY OF U.S. FORCES, IF NOT ALL OF THEM, WOULD BE SAFELY
BACK HOME. UNFORTUNATELY, THE ROSY FORECAST PUT OUT BY THE WHITE
HOUSE AND THE PENTAGON IN 2002 PERISHED IN THE HARSH REALITY OF
IRAQ. THE FAILURE TO PLAN FOR THE POSTWAR PERIOD HAS THUS FAR
CREATED LESS SECURITY FOR THE WORLD, GREATER HEARTACHE FOR IRAQ
AND EXTRAORDINARY COSTS FOR OUR COUNTRY.
AS OF TODAY, NEITHER THE AMERICAN
PEOPLE NOR THE CONGRESS KNOWS HOW THE PRESIDENT INTENDS TO GET
AMERICAN TROOPS OUT OF IRAQ. INSTEAD VIRTUALLY EVERY DAY THE ADMINISTRATION
OFFERS NEWS FOR HOW DISCOURAGING EVENTS ON THE GROUND IN IRAQ
ARE ACTUALLY POSITIVE SIGNS. HERE IS WHAT IS INDISPUTABLE: 2,348
AMERICAN SOLDIERS ARE DEAD. 17,469 ARE INJURED. 262 BILLION TAXPAYER
DOLLARS HAVE BEEN SPENT. IF OUR TROOPS REMAIN IN IRAQ FOR AT LEAST
THREE MORE YEARS, HOW MANY MORE WILL DIE? HOW MANY MORE WILL BE
INJURED? HOW MANY MORE HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WILL IT
COST?
BY ALL ACCOUNTS, THE INSURGENCY
REMAINS STRONG AND IS CONSTANTLY ATTACKING AND KILLING AMERICAN
SOLDIERS, IRAQI SOLDIERS, AND IRAQI CIVILIANS. EVERY DAY THERE
IS ANOTHER BOMBING, ANOTHER BRUTAL IMAGE ON THE TV THAT REFLECTS
THE CHAOS THAT PASSES FOR AN AVERAGE DAY IN IRAQ. SECTARIAN VIOLENCE
IS RAMPANT. THE ETHNIC STRIFE IS SO GREAT THAT SHIITES AND SUNNIS
LIVING IN MIXED NEIGHBORHOODS ARE FLEEING FOR THE SAFETY OF ETHNIC
ENCLAVES. IN RECENT MONTHS, THERE HAVE BEEN MORE AND MORE GROUPS
OF BODIES FOUND, HANDS BOUND, SHOT IN THE BACK OF THE HEAD OR
BEHEADED AND MANY IRAQIS HAVE COME TO BELIEVE THAT THEIR OWN IRAQI
INTERIOR MINISTRY IS PARTICIPATING IN THESE DEATH SQUAD-STYLE
KILLINGS.
ACCORDING TO OUR AMBASSADOR, THE
POTENTIAL IS THERE FOR ALL-OUT CIVIL WAR. THAT, MY FRIENDS, IS
AN UNDERSTATEMENT. AS FORMER PRIME MINISTER ALLAWI CONCEDES, A
LOW-LEVEL CIVIL WAR IS ALREADY BEING WAGED IN IRAQ. THE SO-CALLED
ENDURING BASES THAT THE PENTAGON HAS BUILT IN IRAQ CERTAINLY CREATE
THE APPEARANCE THAT THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION INTENDS FOR THE UNITED
STATES TO OCCUPY IRAQ INDEFINITELY, UNNECESSARILY FOSTERING ILL
WILL AMONG THE IRAQI POPULATION AND THROUGHOUT THE ARAB WORLD.
OIL PRODUCTION, HOUSEHOLD FUEL AVAILABILITY,
AND ELECTRICITY PRODUCTION ARE LOWER THAN THEY WERE TWO YEARS
AGO. IRAQIS HAVE ELECTRICITY HALF OF EACH DAY. ABOUT 32% OF IRAQIS
ARE UNEMPLOYED. THE LIST OF THESE PROBLEMS, MR. PRESIDENT, GOES
ON AND ON AND ON. SUPPORTERS OF THE WAR TOUT THE IRAQI FORCES
THAT ARE STANDING UP AND TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR SECURITY, YET
IT HAS BEEN REPORTED THAT NOT A SINGLE IRAQI SECURITY FORCE BATTALION
CAN OPERATE WITHOUT U.S. ASSISTANCE. THE IRAQI POLICE FORCE IS
PLAGUED BY ABSENTEEISM AND MILITIA INFILTRATION. THE LEVEL OF
INCOMPETENCE IS HIGH ENOUGH THAT U.S. FORCES ARE RELUCTANT TO
HAND OVER THEIR BEST WEAPONS TO THE IRAQIS.
YOU WILL ALSO HEAR SUPPORTERS OF
THE WAR POINT TO THE THREE ELECTIONS AS PROOF OF PROGRESS. YES,
THERE HAVE BEEN ELECTIONS. BUT AS THE CURRENT IMPASSE MAKES CLEAR,
ELECTIONS ARE JUST THE BEGINNING. AND WHILE THOSE ELECTED HAVE
BEEN DELIBERATING FOR THE PAST THREE MONTHS, UNABLE TO REACH CONSENSUS
OVER THE MAKEUP OF THE NEW IRAQI GOVERNMENT, INSURGENTS HAVE BEEN
EXPLOITING THE POWER VACUUM TO KILL, TO MAIM, AND TO INSTILL TERROR
AND FEAR.
SUPPORTERS OF THE WAR ALSO POINT
TO OUR RECONSTRUCTION EFFORTS. BUT BILLIONS OF RECONSTRUCTION
DOLLARS HAVE BEEN MISUSED, MISSPENT OR LOST BY AMERICAN CONTRACTORS
LIKE HALLIBURTON AND IRAQI MINISTRIES, INCLUDING THE MINISTRY
OF OIL. WHILE IN IRAQ RECENTLY, MR. PRESIDENT, AS A MEMBER OF
THE SENATE SELECT COMMITTEE ON INTELLIGENCE, I SAT DOWN WITH REPRESENTATIVES
OF THE OIL MINISTRY TO DISCUSS THE ISSUE OF GRAFT IN IRAQ'S OIL
SECTOR. AFTER I REPEATEDLY POINTED TO INDEPENDENT ANALYSES DOCUMENTING
THE SERIOUS CORRUPTION PROBLEMS WITHIN THE IRAQI OIL SECTOR, THE
IRAQI OFFICIALS FINALLY ACKNOWLEDGED THAT THERE WERE "SMALL
PROBLEMS WITH GRAFT IN IRAQ'S OIL SECTOR." CONSIDERING THAT
OIL ACCOUNTS FOR MORE THAN 90% OF THE COUNTRY'S REVENUE, THIS
OUGHT TO BE EXTREMELY DISTURBING TO THE CONGRESS AND PEOPLE ALL
ACROSS AMERICA.
JUST AS THE PRESIDENT MADE THE CASE
TO GO TO WAR, THE PRESIDENT OWES IT TO THE CONGRESS AND THE AMERICAN
PEOPLE TO COME TO CONGRESS AND LAY OUT HIS PLAN AND HIS BUDGET
FOR ACHIEVING A LASTING PEACE IN IRAQ. CONGRESS OWES IT TO THE
AMERICAN PEOPLE AND THE INSTITUTION TO VOTE. IF THE PRESIDENT
REFUSES TO COME TO CONGRESS IN THE COMING WEEKS WITH HIS PLAN
AND HIS BUDGET TO WIN THE PEACE IN IRAQ, CONGRESS OWES IT TO THE
AMERICAN PEOPLE TO VOTE UP OR DOWN ON WHETHER TO KEEP AMERICAN
TROOPS IN IRAQ FOR AT LEAST THREE MORE YEARS.
THE PRESIDENT'S CASE FOR WINNING
THE PEACE IN IRAQ SHOULD ADDRESS THESE CONCERNS. FIRST, HOW THE
PRESIDENT CAN HELP MAKE THE IRAQIS SELF-RELIANT SO THAT THEY CAN
DEFEAT THE DEADLY INSURGENCY. SECOND, HOW THE PRESIDENT INTENDS
TO HELP SHIITE, SUNNI AND KURDISH LEADERS BREAK THE POLITICAL
IMPASSE SO THAT THEY CAN FORM A UNITY GOVERNMENT. THIRD, HOW THE
PRESIDENT INTENDS TO PUT IRAQI PEOPLE BACK FROM THE BRINK OF ALL-OUT
CIVIL WAR AND THE SPECTER OF ANOTHER RWANDA OR DARFUR. FOURTH,
HOW THE PRESIDENT INTENDS TO HELP REBUILD THE IRAQI INFRASTRUCTURE
AND ENSURE THAT IRAQIS HAVE ACCESS TO BASIC SERVICES LIKE ELECTRICITY
AND CLEAN WATER. AND FIFTH, HOW THE PRESIDENT INTENDS TO BRING
OUR TROOPS HOME FROM IRAQ.
IF NEED BE, MR. PRESIDENT, IN ORDER
TO BE SENSITIVE TO NATIONAL SECURITY MATTERS, I WOULD NOT BE AVERSE
TO THE SENATE MOVING INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION TO CONSIDER PORTIONS
OF THE PRESIDENT'S PLAN AND HIS BUDGET FOR SECURING THE PEACE
IN IRAQ. I SIMPLY ASKED THE PRESIDENT TO COME TO THE CONGRESS
AND DESCRIBE HIS PLAN AND HIS BUDGET SPECIFICALLY AND LET CONGRESS
CONSIDER ITS POTENTIAL TO SUCCEED BEFORE THE CONGRESS WITH ITS
SILENCE CONSENTS TO THREE MORE YEARS OF VERY COSTLY INVOLVEMENT
IN IRAQ. THE VOTE THAT I CALL FOR TODAY IF HELD IS NOT GOING TO
BE ABOUT CUTTING AND RUNNING. IT'S NOT GOING TO BE ABOUT WHO COMES
UP WITH THE BEST SPIN. IT WILL BE ABOUT HOLDING THE PRESIDENT
AND THE CONGRESS ACCOUNTABLE. THE VOTE WILL HOLD THE PRESIDENT
ACCOUNTABLE FOR PRESENTING A PLAN AND A BUDGET FOR SECURING THE
PEACE. AND THE VOTE WILL HOLD THE CONGRESS ACCOUNTABLE BY MAKING
IT FINALLY ACT LIKE A COEQUAL BRANCH OF OUR GOVERNMENT.
MR. PRESIDENT, I YIELD THE FLOOR.
# # #